What lies beneath the decrepit shingles, unsealed openings, gaps, open electrical lines, and the improperly repaired Bitman/torchdown roof is beyond belief.
The image to the right is a huge hole, nearly 24" across, "repaired" with sheet metal pounded into place. Imagine if one of the solar repairmen had fallen through this mess?
What lies beneath the leaky roof are water stains on the rafters, wet insulation, and mildew stains.
Beneath that, lies water stained Sheetrock, stucco, broken paint, water-popped Sheetrock nails, and ceiling stains throughout.
Huge kudos to SolUp, the people who installed the solar. They were our first real clue that the owner has not told the truth when he said the roof was in "good shape" and that "the solar company wouldn't have installed the panels on a bad roof."
When SolUp estimated the roof of 8737 Rancho Destino, their sales person kept records of his conversation with the owner of the home, Mark Vasquez. Those records indicate that
A:They would not install solar on the east-facing roof per the owners request, as it was too unstable, unsafe, and wouldn't support the panels.
B: The west facing roof had reached the end of its life span. It needed to be replaced prior to installing solar. SolUp went so far as to provide the owner with written estimates of roof replacement/re-shingling. the owner refused the estimates and insisted solar be installed over the very old roofing material. In short, he knew the roof was bad, insisted on solar installation, knowing he was listing the home for sale, and I believe Mr. Vasquez and Ms. Truong felt any buyer would miss this huge issue, and felt no sense of moral responsibility to inform any buyer of the issue. It felt odd when Mr. Vasquez told three of us that the "roof was in good condition, but would need to be replaced someday..."
As someone recently said, "there is truth, and then there are alternate facts." There is nothing truthful in saying, suggesting, intimating, or believing the roof is in any condition other than "end-of-life." The current condition of the roof is directly responsible for leaks in the attic and into the house, creating a health and safety issue that the owners attempted to cover up through their misinformation and silence when queried.
The photos above are an exceptionally small representation of the dozens of photos our inspector and myself captured while on the roof. To see the results of the roof damage, be sure to check out the pages on The Leaks.
None of this would have been an issue had Aaron Taylor and Kolleen Kelley properly managed the sale, managed the seller, and been active, engaged agents respecting the Buyer's Agent, the Buyer, and been aware of the house they were attempting to pass off as "immaculate." (The image below is from the Zillow Listing. Note the claim of "Stunning Gem.... immaculate and very well maintained..."
This house has seen zero maintenance in years (in my somewhat knowledgeable opinion).
Our Master Inspector, highly respected and recognized in this industry, held a similar opinion. Maintenance simply wasn't happening at any recent period of time, likely not since the home was acquired in 2013.
The owner of the home signed a legally binding disclosure that the roof had no known issues.
The owner had also verbally indicated to several of us that he "had been on the roof many many times, and had crawled from one end of the attic to the other many many times."
Yet...SolUp, the company that installed the solar panels, had notified the owner of roofing issues prior to installing the roof.
In my opinion, it is inconceivable that he would not have been aware of the very obvious, very damaged roof.
Worse yet, is that Mr. Vasquez is employed in the real estate/mortgage/appraisal industry, and in the words of Aaron Taylor, "Mr Vasquez knows how these things go." In other words, he should absolutely be aware of the repercussions of being less than forthright on an SRPD.
The real estate agent is responsible for ensuring these legally binding documents are accurate, complete, and truthful. Not only did Mr. Taylor (and by extention eXp Realty fail to do so, I believe Mr. Taylor had not ever physically visited the home he was selling.
Copyright © 2019 The Broken Home (concealed crap) - Social Commentary Fair Use. All words presented here are of a personal opinion and do not represent the opinions of anyone I work for, live with, or with whom I do business. Photographs are for your own adjudication; I have published my personal interpretation of the photographs and how they relate to what I feel is an intentional deception on the part of the Seller and their agents, Aaron Taylor and Kolleen Kelley.